Some retailers are closing stores in weaker-performing locations to focus on Web sales and more luxury spots
A few years ago, Restoration Hardware had three Denver-area stores scattered in malls. Today, the furniture chain has just one new one: a palatial, four-story gallery with a rooftop garden. Retailers from Gap Inc. to Abercrombie & Fitch Inc. are abandoning a decades-old strategy of growing sales by blanketing cities with stores as consumers do more of their shopping online and less at the mall. The shifting shopping habits have prompted chains such as Williams-Sonoma Inc. and Macy’s Inc. to close stores in secondary malls to focus on web sales and more upscale shopping centers.
Restoration Hardware Holdings Inc. closed its three older Denver-area stores and last fall opened the 70,000-square-foot flagship at the Cherry Creek Shopping Center, an upscale mall that also is home to Burberry and Brooks
Brothers. Restoration Hardware declined to discuss its new approach, but its change in direction is part of a redesign of the nation’s commercial centers—a reversal of the “malling” of America.
“With technology, retailers don’t need that extra store in a marginal market,” said William Taubman, the chief operating officer of Taubman Centers Inc., which owns Cherry Creek and mainly operates high-end, or so-called “A” malls.
That is widening the gap between the country’s most productive malls and weaker properties, executives and analysts said. Once-solid regional “B” malls that thrived for years are losing shoppers and tenants to the “A” malls—those with sales per square foot in excess of $500, according to Green Street Advisors. The research firm estimates that about 44% of total U.S. mall value, which is based on sales, size and quality among other measures, resides with the top 100 properties, out of about 1,000 malls. Almost all of the 40 stores that Macy’s closed last year were in “B” or “C” malls, according to Green Street. For already weak malls, the loss of an anchor can accelerate a downward spiral that leads to other vacancies.
Not all “B” malls are struggling, however.
“If they are the only game in town, they are less at risk,” said DJ Busch, a senior analyst at Green Street. What undermines them is when a better mall opens nearby. That was the case when The Mall at University Town Center opened in
Sarasota, Fla., in 2014, and pulled a number of tenants out of nearby Westfield Southgate mall, including Williams-Sonoma, Dillard’s and Saks Fifth Avenue. Mall owners disagree about whether the Internet is their main problem. They
point to demographic changes that redirected population and income growth away from malls built years ago, along with a real estate glut that has left the U.S. with 24 square feet of retail space per person, compared with 15 for Canada, 10
for Australia and 5 for the U.K., according to the International Council of Shopping Centers.
They also note that e-commerce amounted to just 7.5% of total fourth-quarter retail sales, according to the U.S. Census Bureau. But if you strip out grocery, home improvement and other items you typically can’t buy at a mall, says Mr.
Busch, e-commerce is closer to 20% of mall sales. Many of the top malls are attracting higher end tenants and leasing space to upscale restaurants and gyms, or hosting events. As a result, shoppers are more apt to bypass smaller, local malls that tend to stock basic items more easily purchased online.
Kelly Woyan-Rudnicki, a writer and movie producer who lives in San Clemente, Calif., said she prefers to drive 30 miles to South Coast Plaza in Costa Mesa, rather than shop at her local mall. In addition to a wide range of stores, from Chanel to Uniqlo, the mall boasts 40 restaurants and coffee shops, and hosts events such as fashion shows and book signings.
“It’s the whole immersive experience,” she said. That is paying off for retailers like Restoration Hardware.
CEO Gary Friedman told analysts in March, that sales were two-to-four times higher in markets where it had switched to giant stores. “We are very early into the transformation of our real estate,” he said. “All of our next-generation design galleries are exceeding plan.” Taubman’s tenants averaged salesper-square-foot of $800 last year, up 57% since 2005. That compares with CBL & Associates Properties Inc., which operates “B” and “C” malls. Its salesper-square-foot rose just 13% to $374 during that period. CBL Chief Executive Stephen Lebovitz said his company’s middle-market malls haven’t benefited as much from the recent boom in luxury sales, but weren’t hurt as much during the recession. As a result, their sales growth has been slower, but more even.
Large mall operators have been divesting lower-performing properties to double down on their most profitable locations. Both Simon Property Group Inc. and General Growth Properties Inc. have spun off lower-quality malls into separate companies so they can focus their capital on higher end properties.
During the past decade, Westfield Corp. has sold 36 lower performing U.S. centers for about $5.9 billion, including five malls sold in December. “As a landlord, we’re investing in the real estate that retailers want to be in,” said Peter
Companies that are acquiring “B” malls see opportunities to improve their productivity. Starwood Retail Partners is trying to add restaurants and new anchors to The Shops at Willow Bend in Plano, Texas, which was 30% vacant in 2014 when it was acquired from Taubman.
Starwood demolished space that had been vacated by Saks Fifth Avenue and plans to rebuild it as a restaurant village. It is also in talks with a potential new anchor tenant, but won’t disclose the name until a deal is signed. “When we’re done, I’m sure it will be an ‘A’ mall,” said Scott Wolstein, Starwood Retail’s chief executive.